In the banking industry there is a term everyone is familiar with: ‘The Big Four’. It is a term used to describe the dominance that the largest four banks possess in the marketplace, with the members traditionally being the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA), National Australia Bank (NAB), ANZ and Westpac.
This market dominance was increased last year, when the ACCC approved a merger between a smaller bank and a member of the Big Four on two separate occasions. The first approval was between the fourth and fifth biggest banks, Westpac and St. George. This merger created the first banking colossus and shot Westpac to number one.
After being the largest bank in Australia for as long as anyone can remember, CBA was not content with being bumped down to number two. A merger with WA’s favourite bank, BankWest, was the catalyst being jumping back into the top position. The move was approved based on a potential liquidity crisis caused by global economic conditions, but with ample time to view the fallout; it may be a move that we won’t see again.
Since the two mergers, growing evidence has emerged that Australia’s Big Four has effectively become the Big Two. Take for example the recent mortgage books growth statistics for the previous financial quarter, where the Big Two accounted for over 85% of the growth achieved by the Big Four in total.
Another repeat of the incredible growth statistics this quarter will see the Big Two officially attain mortgage books more than twice the size of the other two banks. Current figures show the market share percentages as:
CBA 34%
Westpac 31%
NAB 18%
ANZ 17%
Outside of the Big Four, other banks are losing their market share at a dramatic rate. The Big Four now hold around ¾ of all mortgages in Australia, which is up from just over ½ last year. The net result of the continued dominance by the big banks is that market competition will suffer, and could potentially spell negative results for the public.
With the Big Two seemingly a permanent market fixture, what will be on the horizon to push Australia towards having one Mega Bank? The influence of the ACCC should prevent any more mergers, so it will have to be achieved through internal strategy and marketing efforts. CBA is in the prime position to emerge as the Mega Bank, as more consumers are looking to move away from smaller banks in this financial crisis.
The global financial crisis has brought with it a lot of fear surrounding the safety of bank funds. Traditionally, the shift of funds to the larger banks is a common trend amongst previous financial crisis’; most notably the Great Depression. So it is no surprise that bank and mortgage accounts are being switched to seemingly safer options.
The mortgage book growth should continue this quarter for CBA and ensure it increases its market share. Last quarter it captured 57% of the total growth of the Big Four and a similar result will ensure its well on the way to becoming Australia’s first Mega Bank.
A profound marketing push has reaped rewards for CBA in the mortgage market. As homeowners look to fix their interest rate to capitalise on the historically low rates on offer, this presents a great opportunity for CBA to lock in these homeowners as customers for a lengthy period of time.
The bank then has ample opportunity to ensure that the customers switch all other banking, loan and credit card products over to them. The customers can be enticed by offering extra home loan discounts or fee rebates. If CBA uses the strategy of capturing the mortgage market, locking them into contracts and then converting them into full banking customers, they may become a Mega Bank within the next three to five years.
Whilst reduced competition generally means a raw deal for consumers, we shouldn’t expect to see too many negative effects from a reduction in bank numbers. The market is saturated with banks, credit unions and other financial institutions, all competing for your business. Frankly speaking, there are too many products, special deals and incentives on offer to be able to determine the best deals in the market.
A less crowded marketplace should lead to further clarity of the banking options available. Hidden fees will become more transparent, and smaller banks will be able to concentrate their efforts on competing with the Mega Bank, rather than the plethora of other competing financial institutions.
Unlike other industries where a purchase is final or a contract is enforced to the letter of the law, the banking industry allows its customers the freedom to change to another bank if for any reason they are dissatisfied. This freedom is the main factor that differentiates the banking industry from other products in the consumer marketplace, and provides a buffer against the negative effects of decreased competition.
At present, the banks main focus is not on customer retention, but rather on oiling the cogs in the profit machine. The mentality is that for every unhappy customer who leaves, one unhappy customer from another bank will come to replace them. It’s no wonder we find revolving doors at their entrances.
If the CBA decides to metaphorically replace the revolving door with an escalator, and switch their focus to providing brilliant customer service, they are a shoe in to become Australia’s first Mega Bank in the next few years.
The public is crying out for a bank to understand their needs and provide the level of service they deserve. But with a long history customer dissatisfaction to overcome, this may be asking too much. Just when will we finally get to see the Mega Bank is anyone’s guess?
